Marking Pen’s Go Head-to-Head

By Afton Warrick 
Often when being coached on the sport of free-motion, via instructional quilting books or online videos, the key players are described vaguely as “blue marking pen” or “air erasable marker”. This left me sidelined about a strategy for forming my notions line-up. Thanks to Clover’s sponsorship, I’ve been playing a little scrimmage so that I can help you form a marking tools dream team.


The Team Line-Up

Without further ado, let’s get on to the serious contenders.
From Left to Right: Water Erasable Marker Fine, Water Erasable Marker Thick, Chacopen Blue w/ Eraser, Chacopen Pink w/ Eraser, Air Erasable Marker, Air Erasable Marker w/ Eraser, White Marking Pen
Here they are in action.
Since the photo settings in the above picture weren’t suitable to show the White Marking Pen, here’s an individual shot.

 

Team Blue Aqua
Conveniently, water erasable markers and pens proudly wear their team color, blue, making them easy to identify. Water Erasable marking tools are your best choice if you will not be quilting immediately following marking. Watch the video below for how to remove them. Just kidding, a little spritzing from a water bottle should do the trick.

Alright, time out is over. Here are the players:

Water Erasable Marker Thick
Roster Notes: Markings appear black on darker fabrics.

Chacopen Blue with Eraser
Roster Notes: Ironing can make markings reappear after being erased with the included eraser. Water removal will take care of this.

Team Vanishing Pink (or Purple)
Air erasable pens and markers sport a pink or purple uniform. They are preferable if you are making a piece that you do not want to expose to moisture. Swamp cooler usage or a location with high humidity can make these pens disappear much more rapidly.

Roster Notes: Check out the Tool School video.

Roster Notes: Put this player in the first quarter, as it may fade within a few hours.
The Emerging Rookie
White Marking Pen Fine
When your other players neglect to show up on the field (in this case, darker, color-saturated fabrics), it’s time to put in your power rookie, the Clover White Marking Pen.
Roster Notes: This pen disappears with ironing or water. It is visible on black or very dark fabrics. It is light activated, and takes a moment to appear on fabric. Check out the Tool School video.
Game Strategies
  • If marking pens are not very visible on a particular fabric, the same will be true of thread; the time-investment required for detailed quilting may be better applied to an area that shows off the effort involved.
  • Marking Pens come in varying thicknesses. Thicker pens make a more visible mark, but vanish less readily.
  • Eraser pens are great for removing small areas of marking. However, remarking in the exact area that was previously erased may not be possible due to residual eraser formula. It is more time consuming to erase by retracing undesirable markings with an eraser than to remove markings with water or air. However, if you only desire to remove a specific section of markings, an eraser pen makes this possible without eliminating all markings within an area. Avoid pressing fabrics that have been marked with a water erasable marker and erased with an eraser pen until water has been thoroughly applied, as it may cause marks to reappear.
  • The White Marking Pen and air erasable pens can be removed with water.
  • If you’ve used fluffy batting, or multiple layers, markings may require additional time or water spritzing for removal. 
  • It may take a couple misting sessions to remove water erasable markings, to make sure no areas have been missed.
Pre-Season

I like to try out different game plays before getting started to determine which free motion designs I ultimately want to use, while not actually putting a mark on the quilt top. When I’m trying out different designs to see how they’ll work in an area, I recruit a Vis-a-Vis marker and flexible chopping mat. I’ve heard of others using a dry erase marker and plexiglass. However, if you accidentally mark on your quilt with and Epo marker, it’s GAME OVER, aka never ever coming out. It’s also recommended to tape the outer edges of your plexiglass or cutting mat to make the edges more noticeable.
Another great option is a Hera Marker. It creates a visible crease, but doesn’t leave a mark requiring removal. It is especially good for marking straight lines.

The Play-Book

Use this diagram to determine which player is your MVP.
On Suspension

Unfortunately, not everyone who shows up for try-outs is destined to make the team. I’d be negligent if I didn’t ward you about Frixion pens. They appear in many quilt shops, though they are not intended for use as quilt marking pens. While Friction pens make a visible mark on fabric that seems to disappear with an iron, it leaves a white shadow behind on certain fabrics and reappears in cold temperatures. Therefore, I cannot endorse their use for marking a quilt. You can also read up on what The Quilt Skipper and Lee of Freshly Pieced said on the subject. As a side note, I don’t recommend using them to draw patterns on paper either. I have done this before, only to leave my sketch in a hot car and have it completely vanish.
Another product I heard rumors of being used to mark quilts is a Crayola Washable Marker. Upon massive spritzing, the marker bled and remained, so I strongly suggest benching these as well.
I also gave the Sewline Duo a trial run. Unfortunately, residual solution remained even after the eraser dried, making it impossible to remark in the same area. Also, the eraser dried out before the life-expectancy of the pen was met.

Thanks for joining me! What marking tools have you tried? What’s your recommended game play?

4 thoughts on “Marking Pen’s Go Head-to-Head

  1. Thank you for pointing out the issues with Frixion pens; I love them for personal use but never on fabric. When the ink “disappears” in heat, just expose it to cold (put in the freezer, for instance) to make it reappear. I have, however, had great success with Crayola washable markers coming out following a normal laundry cycle.

    • Ah ha! I should put my patten design in the freezer and see if that brings it back. I’m optimistic because it worked for fabric. That’s good to know about the Crayola markers. Even though spritzing might not do the trick, it’s certainly less dire if a good rinse cycle can alleviate the issue.

  2. I do adore a sports analogy! Thanks for all the info ! I thought my white pen wasn’t working, I didn’t realize it didn’t show up immediately.

    • You are very welcome! I had the same initial thought with the White Marking Pen because when my non-Clover marking pens didn’t immediately show up, it was because they had dried out. Now that I have a better understanding of the White Marking Pen works, I try to make sure I’m working in a well-lit area and give it a few seconds to get activated.

Share your thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s